Coming out on “Sister Wives”

Okay, I’ll admit that I sometimes watch reality shows about family situations that are different from my own.  I’m interested in what makes people tick, in how they are different from me, and in how we are the same.

This last week, I was really impressed with the positive way that Mariah’s coming out as gay was portrayed on Sister Wives.  With so many people watching this series, I believe that this has real potential to make an impact on people’s attitudes.  While TLC did make the decision to sensationalize the title of the episode, calling it “A Shocking Revelation”, that probably increased viewership and, therefore, the potential impact.


Sister Wives is a TLC series which follows Kody Brown, his four wives Meri, Janelle, Christine, and Robyn, and their 18 children.  The Browns are members of a fundamentalist LDS (Mormon) religion which follows the practice of polygamy (unlike the mainstream Mormon Church). The family’s stated goal in originally doing the series was to show that people living this lifestyle could be nice normal folks (with big families) and not be the creepy men we see on trial who marry off their underage girls to older men.

On the most recent episode, Mariah (first wife Meri’s 21-year-old only biological child) informed her 5 parents and grandmother that she had something to tell all of them together. With two of the other older girls recently having announced their engagements, there was speculation that it might be something along those lines. Instead, with much nervous excitement, Mariah grinned and burst out with, “I’m gay!”

Almost immediately, the parents and grandmother told Mariah how proud they were of her and how happy they were for her.  Asked to share her story, she revealed that she had from time to time felt attracted to other girls, but had always pushed the feeling away, having been told that being gay was “evil”.  Kody, at that point was horrified and asked, “Did we make you feel that way?”  Mariah was quick to reassure him that it was never the family, but it was their church and its teachings that made her feel she had to be something she wasn’t.  She said later that she had never been afraid to tell her parents, but rather was happy and excited to share what she had learned about herself.

While all of the parents had been surprised by the news, Meri had the hardest time, even though she smiled and told Mariah she loved her.  Their relationship had been strained for some time by what Mariah saw as her mother’s betrayal of the family during a “catfishing” fiasco where Meri had been targeted by a “man” (long story…).  Meri felt bad that they weren’t close enough for her daughter to have shared her journey with her.

Later, when alone with Kody and Robyn, Meri asked Kody and Robyn how they had seemed so happy for Mariah.  Kody said that it wasn’t that they were happy that she was gay per se, but rather that they were happy that she had discovered her true self.  Kody had had to re-examine his attitudes about gay people years earlier when Robyn came into the family, because she had several gay friends.  He also realized that with 18 children, the chances were that at least one of them might identify as gay.  He decided that his job as a father was to love his children and to create a space where they would always feel safe, no matter what.  He has always expressed openness towards his children choosing their own spiritual and life paths.  A very enlightened man, in many ways, even though his collective households run somewhat as a patriarchy.

All in all, the love, unconditional acceptance, and joy that were expressed to Mariah must have made the coming out experience a very positive one for her.  Viewers were treated to a family truly being happy for their daughter, in that she had come to know herself and to find out what she believes will make her happy.  Mariah later said (in People magazine) that she hopes talking about her sexuality on TV will help others who are like her.  “Not everyone will accept you, but you deserve to be happy, and I want them to know it’s okay.”

6 thoughts on “Coming out on “Sister Wives”

  1. I don’t watch this show (although i watch plenty of reality TV). I wonder if, if you have 18 kids, you can be a little calmer if one of them does something that you would theoretically find problematic? As opposed to if you have one or two? I also wonder (without knowing much about this) if the idea that you are sealed to your family in eternity makes it easier to take the long view on stuff like this?


    • I think that Mariah being Meri’s only biological child was one of the reasons that the revelation hit Meri harder. She said that she had imagined helping her prepare for her wedding, meeting her future son-in-law, being there for the birth of her children, etc. It was pointed out that there could still be a wedding and children in Mariah’s future, but of course it would not be quite as she imagined it. And Meri had always wanted to also have a son and figured she could at least have a son-in-law.
      Being together for eternity is an interesting concept. Now that some of the children have left that religion, I wonder how being together for eternity would be affected. Mariah couldn’t reconcile the idea of a religion that couldn’t accept who she was and now says that she is spiritual but not religious.


      • I don’t believe a child can be unsealed even if they leave the church. Resigning would mean you couldn’t attain the Celestial Kingdon, but you could still be saved after you died (e.g., by posthumous baptism) and then the sealing would be valid. I think. Not an expert on this particular church.

        Whereas this was a huge concern for my Lutheran mother, that we would be separated in eternity after I became a Jew.


        • I’m not sure if they’ve resigned or just fallen away. It’s interesting too that a couple of them tried to join the mainstream LDS Church and were refused entry, because their parents are public polygamists.
          I somehow think we’ll all meet up somewhere regardless of religion.


          • That’s really unfortunate, as it’s not their fault that their parents are polygamists … uch. Sins of the fathers and all that, I guess.

            I’ve gone over to the contemporary Jewish point of view which is that we don’t know exactly what happens and everyone is free to take that how they please. (Historically there have been all kinds of views in Judaism including something more like a “heaven” or transmigration of souls back to earth.) My own position is that we probably just die and are eaten by worms … but I would never venture to say anyone is wrong. The evidence is too scanty (lol).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.